Thursday, May 2, 2013

No Right Way


I inadvertently set off a bit of a firestorm here earlier this week. My six-year-old had refused to stay in bed for the fourth day in a row, pitched a fit, and after failing to respond to reason, was left to solve her own problem by crying. The whole thing wore me out and reminded me of sleep training my infants, so I wrote about it.

Maybe I communicated poorly and made the whole thing sound a lot more dramatic than it was, but that post really upset some people. Most of those people expressed their feelings as concern for my poor child, but what they really were doing was judging me as a parent. They told me that my way was the Wrong Way, which implies there is a Right Way (their way) to parent.

There is no Right Way. If you have read a book, watched a video, or been sold a product that promises you are doing things the Right Way, you have been bamboozled. You have purchased only a book, a video, or a product--not the solution. There is no manual, no single solution, and no Right Way.

My children are 9 and 6, so I am a decade removed from advice in parenting manuals and online mommy forums. I don't much care how others think I should parent, and I absolutely want no part of any argument about it.

I'm fairly confident that if you provide adequate food and shelter, love your children, treat them with respect, and teach them to do the same, that the other little decisions will all come out in the wash.

Want to co-sleep? Knock yourself out. Wasn't my thing.

Are you a baby wearer? That's lovely. More power to you. Also not for me.

Did you Ferberize? OK, whatever. If it was a reasonable attempt to solve a problem you and your child were facing, then rock on.

Breast is best and all, but it's not for everyone. Was your baby nourished and growing? Then congratulations, you did a swell job.

Same if you work or stay home, have hired help or not, have a chemical-free home and an additive-free diet or indulge in the occasional 409 and a Freeze-Pop.  Really, it's all going to be ok.

I think most mothers of older children would agree with me. The Right Way proponents tend to be new to this job. They feel ill-prepared and overwhelmed and look for answers and instruction. They search for a way to feel in control and find it in The Right Way. I hope they have found the right way for them, and I hope they feel some level of control. I also hope they realize that the perfect solution in their home is not the solution for everyone.

Love your children. Care for them. Find your own way, and please let me find mine. I'll do the same for you, and all our kids will be just fine.

Comments here are moderated for spam. Your comment will not appear immediately, but likely will soon. Comments are encouraged, especially if they are nice.

If you'd like to continue the conversation or find links to other material I've found interesting, head over to the Flotsam of the Mind Facebook page and Like the page.


  1. AMEN!! :)


  2. I could not have put it better myself! Nobody has all the answers...Each home, and more importantly, each child is different. As a mum to four daughters aged 7 and under, I know that I have to treat each child individually. There is no one-size fits all in parenting, and eventually, most parents come to realize that.

    We should not be so quick to judge other parents. Most of us are doing our very best at what can sometimes be a very tough job. It may not be always 'easy', sometimes it is frustrating, sometimes it is overwhelming but I would like to think (and hope) that in most cases, the needs and best interests of the child are to the forefront of most parents minds when deciding how to parent them.

    Our most important job as parents is to love and cherish our children. Once you do that, and your children are in no doubt of it.... then you have done a very good job!

    I do not know Cynthia other than from what I have read of her in her blog. I have however taken the time to read many of the beautiful posts she has written about her children in the past. I would perhaps suggest that anybody who has not done that, those who still may have concerns, or those that read her recent post as a stand-alone piece, might take the time to do the same.

    1. Thank you! It's good to know that I am not only showing my worst self on the blog.

  3. This was great! Know one can or should judge your parenting by a post from your blog!! Well-said!

  4. Nicely put... I suspect you put a lot of thought into that post and it shows. Until you see the depths at which some parents take care of their children ( which I have in the hospital) you have no right to judge

    1. Thanks, David. I don't even want to know the kind of things you've seen.